Underinsurance occurs when the amount insured is lower than the true cost of repairing, rebuilding, or replacing what has been lost.
When a claim arises, the shortfall does not disappear. It becomes the policyholder’s responsibility. This is often discovered at the worst possible moment, when cash flow is under pressure and recovery is urgent.
Rising construction costs, labour shortages, supply chain disruption, and inflation have significantly increased rebuild and replacement costs in recent years. Many insurance policies, however, are still based on figures that were set years ago and never properly reviewed. Even modest changes over time can compound into a significant gap.
The impact is not limited to property damage alone. Underinsurance can affect claims for partial losses through average or proportional settlement clauses, meaning insurers may only pay a percentage of the claim if the total sum insured is inadequate. A building insured for 60% of its true rebuild cost may only receive 60% of the claim payout, even for smaller losses.
Regular reviews, accurate valuations, and a clear understanding of what your policy covers are essential. Insurance is not a set-and-forget product. It needs to keep pace with the real-world cost of rebuilding, replacing, and recovering.
As brokers, our role is to help identify these gaps before they become financial liabilities. Addressing underinsurance early is almost always less costly than discovering it after a loss. If you are unsure, give us a call for some advice